• Get the App
  • Help & Support
  • My Bookings
  • Trips
  • Partner with StayNow
  • Hotel image
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    View all 9 images
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    View all 9 images
    Hotel image
    +8 Images

    Nottinghams Tavern

    4.2

    913 Reviews

    This rating is verified by Google.

    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    View all 9 images
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    Hotel image
    View all 9 images
    Hotel image
    +8 Images

    Overview

    Reviews

    Nearby

    About The Restaurant

    Nottinghams Tavern in Big Bear Lake offers a cozy pub experience with a menu of American fare, craft beers, and cocktails, featuring live entertainment and a warm, rustic atmosphere.

    Great Food
    Great Breakfast
    Awesome Drinks
    Timings:
    Closed
    Price Category:
    $$
    Parking:
    Paid Parking Available
    Special Diets:
    Vegetarian Friendly
    Vegan Options
    Gluten Free Options
    Charming atmosphere
    Friendly Staff
    Phone:
    909-866-4644
    Email:
    NA
    Website:
    https://nottinghamstavern.com/

    Reviews

    All the reviews posted for this hotel are sourced from Google on June 17, 2025.

    Martha Rios

    June 17, 2024

    1.0

    Where should I start!? When we arrived there was a couple having there drinks and ordering. Other then that it was only us. Waitress took our order. She had a very positive and happy attitude. Once our meal arrived it was downhill from there. We order fried pickle and artichoke and spinash dip. Big chunks of artichoke and spinash no cheese at all. Very dry. It was HORRIBLE!!! My husband ordered the filet mignon RARE with a baked potato and Brussels sprouts. When she brought the order the steak was over cook and the bacon wrapped around it was raw!! The food was flavorless!! My Notti burger was dry and the bacon was old! Terrible food! Never again. I don't recommend this place at all! At the end my husband had to go find our waitress because we were forgotten. $98 down the drain! Just a terrible experience. The only thing nice was the weather. Father's day weekend it was almost empty should of seen the red flag or read the reviews!

    Rotphannee Rose

    July 13, 2024

    4.0

    We went to this place for date night, and the patio had a live band. The service was good, and the drinks were nice, but the food was just okay! The evening was packed because it was Friday night, and there were only four waitresses so long waits for food and drinks.

    Asta Li

    February 16, 2025

    3.0

    waited an hour+ for food but the food was nice. service took very long and they forgot to give us utensils at first, did not check up on us at all in the hour that we were waiting like they forgot about us, serviced others first that arrived after us 🤨

    Bridget Wright

    July 07, 2024

    3.0

    The drinks were great and the service was good, but the food was just okay. The flat bread pizza was good, but it definitely could have used some sauce. My husband's steak was at least 20 % grizzle. The Jasmine rice was a cylindrical blob of mush with a drizzle of balsamic on top. We saw others getting burgers and they looked great. I would like to go back and try breakfast. It could have been an off night. The staff is courteous and helpful and we didn't have to wait long for service. The ambiance was great. They have indoor and outdoor seating and an area at the bar for dining. It has a rustic and antique decor. I am interested in staying at the lodge on our next visit. Overall it was a nice experience.

    Lauren K

    December 30, 2024

    5.0

    Came on Christmas morning, and they were quite busy so it was a little bit of a wait to sit down. Not a problem at all to us, they reminded us that they'll be a bit every few minutes. The food was your typical American breakfast, nothing to go absolutely crazy about, but it was very decently priced. Would love to try the eggs benedict next time. The service was amazing too, the bartender had mostly been serving our table and he was very friendly. Thank you for working on Christmas day!

    Hotels Nearby
    No Hotels Nearby